
I have been studying many different ways to perform electronic music live over the years, and have tried just about all of them. I’ve done all hardware sets, all software software sets, full-on totally sequenced performances (those never worked out well) and totally improvised sets (those are great or totally suck) and have come to hard and fast rules for myself as far as what I will and will not do in a live set. It all comes down to the live aesthetic and integrity as an artist. I really believe in music as art rather then product, and a live musical performance is exactly that – a live performance. For me there is no difference between a live electronic music performance and a jazz band performance.
So, the rules. Some of these are ‘don’ts’ and some are ‘do’s’. The don’t are things that some people do and still consider it a ‘live performance’. Why don’t I consider it a live performance? Because when you do them in a set it really does feel like cheating. And, if it feels like cheating it has to be cheating. The do’s, well, when they happen right they just feel so right. With art I am all about the feel. That isn’t to say that I don’t have rules, because I certainly do, I just think that feel is perhaps the most important part of a live performance.
Ok, here we go.
#1 – No mixing of tracks into the live set.
Some people do it, none ever admit to it, and for me it is something I am just not interested in. It is so obvious when you hear a live set with tracks in them. I can think of several that I was in person for and several that friends (non-producers) turned me on to. They were so dense, and so layered and so composed that there is no way that it could all be live. Sorry, if you are playing tracks you aren’t performing live. This is called the milly vanilly.
#2 – No mixing of ’stems’ in the live set.
Stems are large parts of songs all arranged and laid out. If someone were to give you the ’stems’ of a song you could, if the stems were prepared properly, simply lay them out and get the original song. I am not interested in that, and again, with so much work pre-done for you it is hardly ‘live’. This is the sneaky cheat as the performance sounds really live, and you can do neat stuff with volume and what not, but it is rather hard to fuck-up playing a live set that is all stems.
#3 – There should be a mix of ‘improv’ and ‘composition performance’.
Just like a ‘real musician’ you should be able to perform you set 3 or 4 times and have it come out relatively similar. By the same token you should be able to improvise with your set and make new things up on the spot.
#4 – If the performer isn’t having fun, no one is having fun.
One of the most magical experiences of a live performance is when the performer is as caught up in the moment and is simply having fun doing what they do. When I am really into performing (or playing my gear, the same way a musician plays an instrument) I totally forget about the audience and just let go. Sometimes I almost fall over as I go to make a change on a sound, or drop the bass, or tweak the treble. That is how I know it is real, when I do something and almost loose my balance.
Use whatever tools you like to use so that you can have fun. Personally I like a lot of hardware and knobs to work with. I like a lot of tactile feedback when I make sounds, and I think it makes for a much more enjoyable viewing experience as well. You can see what I am doing as I am doing it. There is a one to one correlation between my actions and the sound. That is fun.
#5 – It is OK to make a mistake, it is LIVE!
While it IS best to be as good as humanly possible, a flawless performance, while desired, isn’t always the best performance. If you are trying to do a trick on a skateboard, and you are in a competition, and you have your run and play it safe, you get an OK score. When you try to do something that is just outside of your reach, and you stretch yourself, sometimes you make it and sometimes you don’t. But, when you DO make it, it is really fantastic. When you don’t, well, just try to recover and see if you can pull it off again. That is how Tony Hawk did his famous ‘900′. Really, people are forgiving when the know you are doing your best to give them something special. Don’t we all love special?
#6 – Do it for yourself first and everyone else second.
By all means don’t be an idiot and try to scare the crowd away like some people do. But, do think about what you want to do for yourself and do exactly that. You do also need to keep the audience in mind, but, it really is all about you doing your thing and them being there to experience it. Assume that they know and understand that everything you are doing is live and that you are totally 100% in control of the music and you will really feel fantastic about it. Come on, they know it’s live.
#7 – Don’t listen to the recording.
Well, I am probably not going to be able to stop you from doing so, but if you do, and it doesn’t feel the same as when you played it, that is because it IS different. You aren’t in the space, you aren’t in front of the people, the sound system isn’t blaring at you. It is totally different. Once thing you can do to add some life to the recording is simulate the ‘club’ sound system. Add some compression, a little room verb, and if the system was shitty, add a little distortion to give it that edge that the cerwins had when you played.
So, that just about wraps up this rant on my feelings towards what a ‘real live performance’. This is all in reference to beat-based dance music. Other forms of live electronic music performance have their own unique set of rules. Perhaps that is another post for another time…